Too late to toilet-train 6-month-old?

DRAFT

On 10/23/08, ...@gmail.com

Hi Judy,

I read your highly informative article on toilet training for puppies.

I'd just like to know if the methods will still work with a 6 month
old puppy who's been with us and spoiled for nearly 3 months now?
During the 3 months that he was with us, we let him run around the
whole apartment and he gets to sleep in our bed or by the bedside if
he's not clean. We have a wire grill with a tray with a puppy diaper
inside in our bedroom and also another one outside our room. If he's
in the room he's supposed to go to the tray in the room, if he's in
the apartment while we're out at work, he's supposed to go to the
tray outside our room since we close the doors to our room when we
go out. We seemed to be making progress when he regularly goes in
the general area of the two trays. Most of the time he goes NEXT to
the tray rather than ON it but we were thinking that he's learning
slowly and soon he will go ON the tray only. However, recently he's
been going in all different places where he didn't used to go
before! And he still goes NEXT to the tray most of the time.

I regret not reading your article when we first got our puppy. We
were so taken in by his cuteness I think we spoiled him and couldn't
bear keeping him in a cage. So, after 3 months of being spoiled, can
we still apply these methods and get results? Do we have to modify
the toilet-training techniques in any way? Also, we are out of the
house during office hours, does this affect his toilet training?

I'd appreciate any advice that you could provide.

Thank you very much for your time and kind attention.

Regards,

xxx



REPLY

David Sing wrote:

1. I am Dr Sing from Toa Payoh Vets. Thank you for your email.
2. Are you staying in Singapore?
3. Can you e-mail a picture of the grill + tray?
4. What is the breed and gender of your puppy?
5. The methods of confinement and routine (of food, exercise, sleep) should work for your puppy who is 6 months now.







E-MAIL TO DR SING
On 10/30/08, ....@gmail.com> wrote:

Hi Dr. Sing,

2. Yes, I am staying in Singapore.

3. I've attached the pictures in this email. We will be moving to a new place on November 15th with almost twice the space. Do let us know if we should get a larger play-pen for Nike. I was thinking of getting two more of the long fence links to make the play-pen a square with the long fence links for sides but then I realized that the long fence links will not connect properly with the two existing long fence links. Any suggestions?

4. Nike is a male Shih Tzu at around 6mo old.


E-MAIL TO DR SING

Flag this message
Re: Query regarding toilet training
Friday, October 31, 2008 7:39 AM
From: Dr Sing

To:...@gmail.com>

-----Inline Attachment Follows-----

1. Thank you for your 2 pictures.

2. In reply, increase his confined area every week by 50 - 100% depending on your resources.

3. My suggestion will be to confine your dog inside a bathroom when you move to a new place. Use the existing panels of fences like a "baby-gate". Put the grill and tray at one end (with his own urine smell on the puppy diaper) if you want him to be trained this way. If you do not have a spare bathroom when you are at work, you do need a bigger playpen when the dog is home alone.


4. CLEAN INSTINCT OF DOGS.
The reason he eliminates outside the diaper is that he is a very clean dog (by instinct) and does not want to step onto the grill.
4.1 I presume you don't wash the grill and tray once a day or regularly. Therefore he does not want to step onto it whenever possible. To get the dog to use only the grill and tray method, the grill and tray must be cleaned as often as possible for very clean dogs.

5. As to his eliminating outside his tray, the most likely explanation is that he has matured. The male hormone testosterone has made him want to urine-mark. Some dogs do mark by passing stools here and there too. Neutering him early (around 6 months) will usually stop this habit.

6. NEUTRALISATION OF URINE SMELL IN YOUR APARTMENT. Some owners find that vinegar:water at 1:3 is effective as the dog can't detect those non-approved areas. Your mop must be free of dog's urine smell too.

7. WATCH OUT FOR SIGNS OF ELIMINATION - sniffing, turning. This is difficult as the dog now urine-marks.

I hope I have answered all your questions. Let me know how you progress.